Posted by M. Wright | Filed in: Blogosphere
In his July 4 post, Independency and Dependency, Josh Ross presents something that’s part straw man argument and part false dichotomy.
After acknowledging that Independence Day will be celebrated for “as long as the US remains the US” and noting ways in which our nation has changed, Ross says what the U.S. actually commemorates on this holiday is “independency.” By using this variation of the term, he suggests Americans are paying tribute to a generic condition of self-sufficiency, rather than a specific, political Independence.
Having defined the holiday as such, Ross then goes on to indicate his prayer that we instead seek dependence upon God.
What we remember on Independence Day is not self-sufficiency, but instead our nation’s birth, our deliverance from tyranny, our political freedom, our equality and our mutual interdependence. The signers declared that they had mutually pledged to each other their “lives,” their “fortunes,” and their “sacred honor.”
And our celebration of Independence is certainly not in conflict with our dependence upon God. The founders wrote that we were entitled by God with political equality, and that our Creator had endowed all men “with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.”
Furthermore, the signers wrote that our Declaration of Independence was supported “with a firm reliance on the protection of Divine Providence.” John Adams wrote that this occasion “ought to be commemorated as the day of deliverance, by solemn acts of devotion to God Almighty,” celebrated each year with a “great anniversary festival.”
It’s clear that Ross misunderstands the nature and character of this great holiday, if not the nation itself, which may help explain why he believes “we need people who will refuse to be defined by American values and principles.”
Should we refuse to be defined by our reverence for the equality of mankind? Should we refuse to be defined by our understanding that our rights come from God? Or by our unique system of checks and balances that protect the people from tyranny? Or by our religious and political freedoms? Or by our representative democracy, our exhaustive justice system and transparent governance? By our history of defending liberty at home and abroad?
Should we be ashamed by our nation’s exploration, innovation, industry, diversity, opportunity and tolerance? Or by our dedication to diplomacy, philanthropy and justice? Should we be ashamed of our people’s generosity and optimism? By our eagerness to forgive our enemies, offer aid and amnesty to the destitute or stand as a beacon of freedom around the world?
I will never refuse to be defined by my belief in these uniquely American values and principles.
Did you see the announcement by the Florida Marlins this week, that they played a “